It makes clear sense to me that tools have done more to change history and make our life better than Rulers. For example, the invention of the bow and arrow made it much easier to hunt more animals for food, thus making food more abundant. But that invention was likely preceded by the spear.
But as some primitive tribes learned to live from what plants produced, eventually he learned he could plant seeds. Later man or humanity learned to domesticate animals. But in addition man invented the plow, with which he was able to cultivate much larger areas of land than ever before. With the benefit of domesticated animals he could use a horse or an ox to pull that plow.
Its interesting that early in the Bible in the book of Genesis, it speaks of domesticated animals and cultivation of the soil. Indicating that who ever wrote Genesis lived in relatively modern times. According to some secular historians, man lived in primitive communist societies without Rulers, police, whips, jails, courts, and or oppressor and oppressed. Lots of knowledge that we benefit from now, was acquired during thousands of years. Like learning to use fire for cooking and keeping warm. And like some of the tools I already mentioned. Tools were needed, but Rulers, as we have today, or as we think of, were not.
In primitive society, obedience was based on respect of elders. If you did not conform, you would be banished from the tribe. In a primitive communal system that required cooperation and NOT competition for existence, banishment from the tribe . meant almost a sure death sentence. That is, unless another tribe adopted you, instead of killing or eating you.
Tools, machines, technology continues to change our life today. One computer can replace what would require a dozen secretaries could do before. It is much easier to outsource jobs. Robots can paint cars, and even weld them.
But tools should be our slaves, and work for us, not just sometimes but all the time. But it appears we today are becoming their slaves and they appear to become our enemies. When the industrial or capitalist revolution first begun, workers thought the machines were the enemy. They thought that by taking sledge hammers and destroying them their problem would be solved. They soon discovered that did not work. They later tried organizing unions. They soon learned that did more to improve their life than destroying the machines. The solution seems to lie in making unions work for us, so that we can make machines benefit us, and become our slaves. Machines should be used to do the dirty disease causing jobs, and we should not have to work the long hours we do now. Machines in other words should be used to shorten the work day as much as possible, but our pay should not be diminished. If we had a union that truly worked for workers, that is exactly what would happen.
If you want to get a better and more detailed explanation of what the materialist conception of history is. I will quote part of a chapter from, Engels Anti Durhing.
"The materialist conception of history starts from the proposition
that the production and, next to production, the exchange of things
produced, is the basis of all social structure; that in every society
that has appeared in history, the manner in which wealth is
distributed and society divided into classes or estates is dependent
upon what is produced, how it is produced, and how the products are
exchanged. From this point of view the final causes of all social
changes and political revolutions are to be sought, not in men's
brains, not in man's better insight into eternal truth and justice,
but in changes in the modes of production and exchange. They are to
be sought, not in the philosophy, but in the economics
of each particular epoch. The growing perception that existing social
institutions are unreasonable and unjust, that reason has become
unreason, and right wrong, is only proof that in the modes of
production and exchange changes have silently taken place with which
the social order, adapted to earlier economic conditions, is no
longer in keeping. From this it also follows that the means of
getting rid of the incongruities that have been brought to light must
also be present, in a more or less developed condition, within the
changed modes of production themselves. These means are not to be
invented, spun out of the head, but discovered with
the aid of the head in the existing material facts of production.
The growing perception that existing social institutions are
unreasonable and unjust, that reason has become unreason, and right
wrong, is only proof that in the modes of production and exchange
changes have silently taken place with which the social order,
adapted to earlier economic conditions, is no longer in keeping."
http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1877/anti-duhring/ch24.htm
:That is from part 3 Socialism, from same book.
Thanks Rick. I hope you are wrong, and working people both in the US and other parts of the world wake up before your scenario becomes fact. It both amazes and saddens me that people, especially college educated people seem to be so easily manipulated by governments. So for that reason you may be right.
ReplyDeleteBut just like man conquered electricity and makes it work for us, instead of just killing us with lightning bolts or burning our forests, we could make those robots, or the economic forces working against us, we could make them work for us. Its as simple as producing for human need instead of for profit. Profit is the only thing standing between jobs, nutrition, health care, and housing for all. It may seem over simplistic, if one does not have a solid base in Marxist economics.
Here is one reason it is that simple. We have the machines to produce the goods we need. We have the idle or unemployed workers that would work them. Even in Marx time it was estimated that it only took 3-4 hours to produce all the necessities of one person or one worker. Today it is probably much less with all the labor saving devices invented since Marx. But under our capitalist system, all production ceases when profits cease. Profits serve as a gas pedal but also as a brake on the capitalist machine.
There are a lot of questions that will come up. It is good to bring up those questions for discussion.
Workers, and I consider anyone that is not supported by capital he or she owns, a worker. college professors, students, unemployed, retired, are all workers, though they may stand aloof from blue collar workers. But under the capitalist system workers are treated like other commodities, or like potatoes. As the number of either goes up, their price goes down. If you graduate too many medical students, the price of Doctors go down. Or if you have a Nurse Practitioner take over some of their skills, that would also cause their price to drop I don't have the link, but in one state, Physicians had to organize into a union to protect their income. If you outsource the jobs of programmers their price goes down, as we have seen.
Today, some jobs or professions have an unfair advantage because of limits that are put in how many students can graduate. Also, if you are born into educated parents, usually that gives you an advantage over parents with little education.
In a planned economy, the playing field will be leveled. We will all have more time, for learning, and for becoming what we enjoy, not so we can stand aloof above people with less education, or because we want to have a two car garage, swimming pool, whatever drives people today. Physical labor will be shared by all, and robots will have the honor of working the mines or other dangerous jobs.
But you can think of this as a debate. And share your doubts or questions.
First Rick, sorry to take so long to respond. Not good for someone seeking to get a blog up and running. I was confused by how you start:
ReplyDelete"everything you say is true; it isn’t up for debate. neither is the fact that our profit driven, capitalist system will never go away."
You seem to agree with everything I had posted but think that the the capitalist system will "never go away". I take that to mean it will exist forever. Perhaps even when the sun and earth have ceased to have exist also. :-) I don't know of anything in the universe that exists forever.
I guess you were using Fortune 500 as your source. So I guess most of us want to be the Alpha dog, why havent we eaten each other up? Now I will agree there are a few dogs in society with most of them in power now. Sometimes workers act like the dogs that rule them. And sometimes Canines or 4 legged dogs act more human than people. I love people, and if i thought the majority were about to bite me, I would hate to be around people. I hope you did not marry and Alpha Wife, and had Alpha Children. And no doubt they do exist, I just hope you were lucky enough to get what I think you mean is the exception.
Howard Zinn, my favorite historian, says when Columbus asked an Indian for one object he would give him 3., that sure does not sound alpha dog to me. Now Colombus truly was a VICIOUS DOG. He would cut the hands of the Indians that would not bring him gold. I wish they had more Alpha dog in them and kiled the bastard. The bastard that the Apha dogs hold up as a hero for us.
The Alpha dogs, the capitalists in power only, are only in power because us humans are way to nice, way to gullible and way to patient, to let them get away with murder..literally We are too nice and let charities exploit not the Alpha in us, to get us to donate for ..good causes.
I think it is unfair to impute the alpha dog quality on working people. But I doubt you did that intentionally as only an Alpha dog would do that.
But you did say this was not up for debate, and here I am debating it still. :-)